The Top 10 Elizabeth Bennets, ranked

Over the past century, our screens have been graced with Elizabeth Bennets of all kinds — and while many have come and gone, our love for them has not. Whether in big-screen movies, TV miniseries, or even a modern-day web show, we’ve all seen our fair share of Lizzy Bennets.

Below, we’ve ranked our top 10 versions of Elizabeth. How does your favorite fare?

10. Amanda Price/Elizabeth Bennet in 2008’s “Lost in Austen”: In this variation of “Pride and Prejudice,” a 21st-century Jane Austen fan named Amanda Price (Jemima Rooper) accidentally trades places with Lizzy, leaving Amanda falling for Darcy and the real Elizabeth becoming a nanny in modern-day society. Neither “Elizabeth” is particularly my favorite.

bridget_jones_diary_hed
No. 9: Bridget Jones (Renee Zellweger)

9. Bridget Jones in 2001’s “Bridget Jones’s Diary”: This is definitely a very loose adaptation of “Pride and Prejudice,” but Bridget (Renee Zellweger) is a nice variation of Elizabeth even though they might not actually have that much in common.

8. Elizabeth Bennet in 2003’s “Pride and Prejudice: A Latter-Day Comedy”: In this adaptation, Lizzie (Kam Heskin) is a Mormon attending college at Brigham Young University. Though the setting and situation may be wildly different from the novel, we still get a glimpse of Mr. Darcy and the smart, strong-willed Elizabeth we know and love.

2015-09-15_10-35-34_957.622x621
No. 7: Lalita Bakshi (Aishwarya Rai) 

7. Lalita Bakshi in 2004’s “Bride and Prejudice”: This Bollywood-esque adaptation includes lots of music and dancing — need I say more? Lalita (Aishwarya Rai) is headstrong and smart, and brings Lizzy Bennet to us in a fresh, diverse way. Still, there’s a little something lacking for me in the chemistry between her and Darcy.

6. Elizabeth Bennet in 1980’s “Pride and Prejudice”: This BBC television adaptation gives us another kind-hearted, lively  Lizzy Bennet (Elizabeth Garvie). But it’s just not my favorite.

Lily_james
No. 5: Elizabeth Bennet (Lily James)

5. Elizabeth Bennet in 2016’s “Pride and Prejudice and Zombies”: Honestly, did you ever really think you would find Lizzy (Lily James) slaying zombies and wooing Mr. Darcy all at the same time? Neither did I, but here she is, and, surprisingly enough, her new character traits work really well (knife-wielding skills included).

4. Elizabeth Bennet in 1995’s “Pride and Prejudice”: Brought to us by BBC, this miniseries presents a classic take on “Pride and Prejudice” and Miss Elizabeth Bennet (Jennifer Ehle) — that Austen fans are sure to love. That said, this Lizzy comes in at No. 4 on my list only because I’m extremely partial to my top three picks.

3. Elizabeth Bennet in 1940’s “Pride and Prejudice”: Greer Garson gives us a beautiful rendition of our beloved Bennet sister. She’s kind, witty, and just about everything else you could expect from a near-picture-perfect Elizabeth Bennet in this black-and-white rendition of “Pride and Prejudice.”

2. Lizzie Bennet in 2012-13’s “The Lizzie Bennet Diaries”: How could you NOT adore Lizzie in this modern-day, vlog-style YouTube adaptation of “Pride and Prejudice.” This Miss Bennet (Ashley Clements) meets all of the qualifications for a  21st-century go-getter. Going to graduate school for mass communications, she’s intelligent, hilarious, and oddly great at impersonating Mr. Darcy.

screen-shot-2014-07-14-at-4-56-38-pm
No. 1: Elizabeth Bennet (Keira Knightley)

1. Elizabeth Bennet in 2005’s “Pride and Prejudice”: Maybe I’m just blindsided by my love for Keira Knightley (and because this version of “Pride and Prejudice” is filmed so beautifully), but I can’t help but put this variation of Lizzy at the top of my list. Smart, witty, and absolutely stunning this is an Elizabeth for the ages.

If you’re looking for more rankings of your favorite “Pride and Prejudice” characters, check out how your favorite Mr. Darcys stacked up here!

Agree with our list? Let us know! Think that we’re way off? Tell us how you would rank your favorite Elizabeths in the comments below!


GIVEAWAY

51Lb+8hfxhL._SX390_BO1,204,203,200_.jpgThe 2019 Jane Austen Summer Program is just about sold out! If you were thinking of registering, sign up today! As a bonus, the next five registrants will receive a free copy of “Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice: A Book-to-Table Classic” — with recipes from Martha Stewart. CLICK TO REGISTER HERE.

2 thoughts on “The Top 10 Elizabeth Bennets, ranked

  1. There is no doubt, in my mind, Jennifer Ehle’s portrayal of Elizabeth Bennet is a classic, and ought to be Number 1. It was actually her mezmerizing performance that made me an Austen fan.

  2. I think we all tend to prefer our first Lizzie. Mine, Elizabeth Garvie, will always rank #1 in my heart. However, I have to put Colin Firth ahead of my #2 Darcy, David Rintoul (Garvie’s costar)!

Leave a Reply to Susan Buonocore Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s